Sign up to get new listings emailed daily! JOIN SIGN IN
Dustin Kreider
REALTOR®
(717) 669-2958
Office: (717) 786-1300

Customer Reviews

  • 5 stars
    71
  • 4 stars
    0
  • 3 stars
    0
  • 2 stars
    0
  • 1 stars
    0

Dustin Kreider
(71 ratings)
5 out of 5 based on 71 ratings.
71 user reviews.
testimonial quote

He helped me get rid of a couple pieces of furniture that I couldnt...before the walk through...he also asked me If I wanted to ride along with him to the closing...he knew I didn't like to drive in the city...

Connie M Criswell
testimonial quote

Dustin was very helpful in selling our home, very quick to respond to questions and came highly recommended by 2 friends who have also had the pleasure of working with him in the past.

nettingvicki
testimonial quote

I started working with Dustin in February 2025 to sell a rental property. He quickly got the property advertised, and shortly after received a respectable offer. After accepting the offer, we discovered that the title to the property had an existing encumbrance. The process of removing the encumbrance took 7 months, but Dustin was able to work with the buyer to keep them informed of the process to correct the title. He did a great job communicating with all parties, and he successfully helped me sell the property in October 2025. If I need to sell another property I will definitely use Dustin again!

Cindy Menches
testimonial quote

Dustin is great! He was very helpful and knowledgeable! Highly recommend!!

DANIEL WALKER
testimonial quote

Dustin is great to work with! Very knowledgeable, responsive, reliable, and a great sounding board when solving issues and making decisions. Thanks!

CLEMENT JANBYE LIN
testimonial quote

Dustin is fantastic to work with, and he was my agent during the first time I sold an investment property. He is very knowledgeable, knows the York, PA area well, and is an expert in the entire process. Dustin guided me every step of the process from start to finish. He is very responsive, kept me updated on each milestone from comp reviews and getting listed, to reviewing offers and going through escrow. He provided valuable advice when it came down to pricing, when we ran into timing challenges with showings and paperwork, and also unforeseen issues with the property as we were getting it listing ready.I couldn't have asked for a better agent to partner with for this first transaction. Already working with him on another listing, and hoping for many more in the future.

CJ Lin
testimonial quote

Dustin was a pleasure to work with throughout the entire selling process. From the moment we started working with him, he was a timely and clear communicator. He has a great knowledge of the local area and set clear & honest expectations at every step. His law background also gives him an advantage in negotiations, while remaining fair and balanced. It was clear that his goal was to achieve the most beneficial outcome and make sure we were always on the same page. His patience and overall demeanor helped us keep a level head during some of the challenges of selling an older home, and in the end, we made it to the finish line with smiles on our faces. Dustin is a true 5-star real estate professional, and we would recommend him to anyone in the area looking to sell or buy.

A Gibbs21
testimonial quote

Dustin is the best, always goes above and beyond.

KYLE G. ALLEN
testimonial quote

Dustin did an outstanding job assisting us with the purchase of our investment property . His expertise in the market's geographic area was instrumental in determining a competitive purchasing price while considering the future resale value for the area. Dustin was very involved in all aspects of the closing from reaching out to title to making sure we get the best deal possible. He was friendly and responsive and I cannot stress enough how valuable it is to have a agent that is responsive!

shemp95
testimonial quote

From the very beginning, Dustin was professional, attentive, and incredibly knowledgeable about the local market. He took the time to understand our needs, answered all of our questions, and provided valuable guidance every step of the way. Not only did he help me sell my home quickly and for a great price, but he also made the process of finding and purchasing my new home smooth and stress-free. Dustin was always responsive, keeping me updated on every detail and ensuring that I never felt out of the loop. His negotiation skills are top-notch, and he worked tirelessly to make sure I got the best deal possible. Five-star service all around!

sarahandtodd16
testimonial quote

Dustin was a pleasure to work with while looking for a home. We had a short sale case with the house we bought and it was a long drawn out process. Dustin always was quick to get back to us with any questions we had, no matter the time or day we called or texted. He was great with explaining everything to us making it easy to understand. I would recommend Dustin to anyone looking to sell or buy a home.

JosiahPetersheim
testimonial quote

Dustin was very responsive with all questions and requests. He was very organized when it was time to put an offer in which gave the selling agent confidence in the offer we submitted.

Zachary Felpel
testimonial quote

Dustin is very knowledgeable and knows the industry well so was great at helping us negotiate a very competitive market. He was very responsive and available for viewings and questions. Thanks Dustin!

andy w shaw
testimonial quote

Dustin was great. Helpful, insightful and very patient explaining the finer points of home buying to someone that’s not very well versed in it. Willing to help make contact with other parties and ensuring the whole process went as smoothly as it could have gone.

hackenberg daniel
testimonial quote

Dustin made it work! We were looking for something very specific and he worked with us tirelessly to make it happen. He was a wonderful support for us and his keen negotiation skills sealed the deal. We recommend him without reservation!

dikal88
testimonial quote

Dustin made it work! We were looking for something very specific and he worked with us tirelessly to make it happen. He was a wonderful support for us and his keen negotiation skills sealed the deal. We recommend him without reservation!

dikal88
testimonial quote

Dustin is honestly the best of the best. His communication skills are exemplarily with always being available to answer any questions you may have. As well as his expertise in his field is shown through constantly thinking outside the box if something at first doesn't work out right away. His connections within the community also don't hurt. We would not have been able to complete this journey without him. Would highly highly recommend! He really will go to bat for his people and you don't see that alot these days. We appreciate him tremendously and will be using him in the future no doubt. Thank you Dustin for everything!

sarah kreider219
testimonial quote

Dustin is honestly the best of the best. His communication skills are exemplarily with always being available to answer any questions you may have. As well as his expertise in his field is shown through constantly thinking outside the box if something at first doesn't work out right away. His connections within the community also don't hurt. We would not have been able to complete this journey without him. Would highly highly recommend! He really will go to bat for his people and you don't see that alot these days. We appreciate him tremendously and will be using him in the future no doubt. Thank you Dustin for everything!

sarah kreider219
testimonial quote

Dustin did an outstanding job. He was quick with responses, informative with our questions and he provided solid advice for things which we did have not have much experience. He helped us coordinate staging, he provided advice on valuation and he did a great job giving us insight into buyers perspectives of the key points of the home including the entrance, kitchen condition and room uses. He was very personable and a pleasure to work with through the entire process. We highly recommended choosing Dustin

cdavidmyers21
testimonial quote

Dustin did an outstanding job. He was quick with responses, informative with our questions and he provided solid advice for things which we did have not have much experience. He helped us coordinate staging, he provided advice on valuation and he did a great job giving us insight into buyers perspectives of the key points of the home including the entrance, kitchen condition and room uses. He was very personable and a pleasure to work with through the entire process. We highly recommended choosing Dustin

cdavidmyers21
testimonial quote

I had the pleasure of working with Dustin to sell my investment property, and I'm thrilled with the results! Dustin's market expertise and strategic approach ensured a seamless process, maximizing the property's value. If you're looking for a real estate professional who understands the nuances of investment properties, I highly recommend Dustin!

epplercraig
testimonial quote

I had a tricky property to sell--which included dealing with a difficult tenant--and Dustin managed it all professionally. I never felt like he was pushing me in any direction that wasn't a good solution for me and obtaining the best price possible ... and he found a buyer quickly. I would totally recommend him.

vicki38151
testimonial quote

I had a tricky property to sell--which included dealing with a difficult tenant--and Dustin managed it all professionally. I never felt like he was pushing me in any direction that wasn't a good solution for me and obtaining the best price possible ... and he found a buyer quickly. I would totally recommend him.

vicki38151
testimonial quote

Dustin was a pleasure to work with, I would highly recommend him! He was very responsive to calls and texts and also helped us find a great property manager for the rental property that we purchased.

lumarda
testimonial quote

Dustin was a pleasure to work with, I would highly recommend him! He was very responsive to calls and texts and also helped us find a great property manager for the rental property that we purchased.

lumarda
testimonial quote

Dustin went above and beyond helping us get into our new home. Dustin was able to assist me with any questions or concerns I had with the home-buying process. Dustin ability to communicate effectively made finding our home easy!

aldenchambers75
testimonial quote

Dustin took care of everything. He is professional and caring and keeps on top of every detail. We highly recommend him for all your real estate needs.

County Cavan Llc
testimonial quote

Dustin is very knowledgeable and great to work with. He was always available to answer questions and provide guidance. We appreciate everything he did in helping us find and buy our perfect home!

Cheryl Buffo
testimonial quote

Dustin is very knowledgeable and great to work with. He was always available to answer questions and provide guidance. We appreciate everything he did in helping us find and buy our perfect home!

Cheryl Buffo
testimonial quote

Dustin is one to go the extra mile every time, bringing all facts and knowledge to the table for a comprehensive detail on every deal. Can’t speak highly enough of his skill set not only as a realtor but also an attorney. The only regret is I have not bought more rental properties with him in the past but, from now on he’s definitely my guy. Dustin is a sure bet for anyone looking to invest in real estate weather it’s you first home or your 10th rental.

jdypj8b9fj
testimonial quote

Dustin was incredible. He helped my wife and I buy our first home. He is a great guy who is very knowledgeable. My wife and I had a very smooth experience buying our first home with Dustin as our realtor! Couldn’t be happier.

dannycmulder
testimonial quote

Personalized service, a team that truly cares about its clients.

Jess Hodgson
testimonial quote

Dustin worked with my business partner and I to identify a rental property. He is extremely knowledgeable & attentive. This is definitely a real estate agent you want on your side if you are in search of a home or investment property. We look to working with him in the future!

tylerlamazebridgwood
testimonial quote

Dustin was great and really made the process seamless for me and my business partner. Always on top of things and very responsive. Dustin would check in every step of the way to update us or let us know if he needs anything from us. Dustin also was always available to provide his expertise and provided value to decision making. I would highly recommend him to anyone looking for a home in an area he covers.

NicoK22
testimonial quote

We didn’t have an exact area that we were interested in but, Dustin was able to map out a geographical area based on our commute to work and family and that really helped narrow in a specific area! Dustin was quick to respond to our questions and very knowledgeable about the entire process. Dustin is very personable and we felt very comfortable having him guide us through this process. He was also very involved in the closing process.

madisonness
testimonial quote

Couldn’t be happier with how Dustin handled renting out my commercial property. From initial phone call to getting the building leased he was very thorough. Would highly recommend Dustin for all your realty needs

rosslawn1985
testimonial quote

he is great to work with did a outstanding job ...stayed in contacted with us and handle the closing for us while we where in kansas . if i rated him on a scale of 1 to 10 with 10 being great id give him a 20

VictorBird
testimonial quote

did outstanding

Victor D Bird
testimonial quote

In August, I used Dustin to sell my previous home. He made that entire process extremely easy and pain-free. I was very pleased with him, his services, and his knowledge of the industry. Since the sale of the last place in August, I’ve been working with Dustin in search of my next house. He’s gone above and beyond and been very patient with me and my search. Even in this difficult market for buyers, Dustin made purchasing my new home about as easy as one could hope for. He was always quick to touch base on newly listed properties that I might be interested in, always willing to make a showing happen as soon as possible even though my search area wasn’t close to his home, and just was extremely punctual in every aspect of the searching and buying process. Unlike other realtors I’ve worked with previously, from start to finish I always felt confident that Dustin had my best interest and was extremely open, honest, and genuine. As long as Dustin’s a realtor, I’ll never use anyone but him again!

zuser20160921113444979
testimonial quote

Dustin was incredibly patient until we decided which direction we wanted to go. He provided a lot of information to help us decide. He walked us step-by-step through each process. He was excellent to work with.

dddavids dd
testimonial quote

If you want an experienced and honest realtor with very quick response time, Dustin is the realtor for you. He was quick to point out things we might’ve missed while at showings and was helpful with giving me his opinions on solid starting offers. I appreciate all his help with getting us our first home, we will definitely be using him in the future when we go to sell.

rteaman25
testimonial quote

Great to work with. Very down to earth. Kept me in the loop. Very Knowledgeable and punctual. Got me more than asking price. Would/will work him again.

IanBippus
testimonial quote

Dustin made the selling process as smooth as possible. He was so easy to work with and made a typically stressful transaction, easy. He is very knowledgeable in all aspects of real estate and was on top of every step of the selling process. I couldn’t have asked for a better realtor for the job!

RebekahSteffy
testimonial quote

If I had to buy or sell another house I would not let anyone except Dustin be my agent. He was always available and had the most up to date information. He made selling my house the best experience I have ever had, and believe me after moving around for twenty three years in the military I have had some doozies.

bigbear979
testimonial quote

Dustin took so much time to help us find a house that was what we wanted. In a normal market, that's a big deal; but in the 2021 housing market, it was so far above and beyond. Dustin drove very far out of his way for multiple showings and never tried to rush us during the process. We always felt comfortable with Dustin handling any communication with sellers, other agents, etc. knowing that he would handle things with our best interests in mind.

reyburnemily
testimonial quote

Dustin was awesome to work with! He got to know us and what we were looking for. He’s extremely knowledgeable and a great communicator. Our overall home buying experience was easy, despite having to wait a while for the perfect home! There was a small issue right before closing which Dustin handled very calmly and professionally. We highly recommend him for anyone looking to buy a home or build on a lot.

Stephanie davis21
testimonial quote

Dustin was great to work with, Very knowledgeable and trustworthy. He was able to guide us in this crazy market and made it very easy. If I need any more homes I’m gonna use him....you won’t be sorry!

kablough
testimonial quote

Dustin was very helpful and informative on my journey to find a home. This was my first time looking at purchasing a home and Dustin made the process go very smooth, and helped me to better understand the process.

aldenchambers75
testimonial quote

GREAT agent. Smart, detailed, responsive and has great connections to the community. He arranged all inspections with reputable companies. I had no knowledge of the area, having a trusted agent made our purchase so much less stressful. Thank you Dustin, we are grateful you were our agent.

gailkovash
testimonial quote

The house that I was selling is located in PA and I live in NV. Dustin was able to handle it a as if we were together all the time. I knew I could trust his advise and suggestions. He certainly went the extra mile helping with this long distance sale. His telephone calls and emails were easily handled. I would absolutely recommend Dustin and his professional attitude.

swkefld
Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 05/16/2026. The listing information on this page last changed on 05/16/2026. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of Delta Media Group MLS (last updated Sat 05/16/2026 5:06:57 AM EST) or Bright MLS (last updated Fri 05/15/2026 5:03:44 PM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Homesale Realty may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility
Federal Housing Equal Opportunity Realtor
Corporate Office - 215 S Centerville Rd. Lancaster, PA 17603
James J Hafer - West Virginia Broker of Record

©2026 BHH Affiliates, LLC. An independently owned and operated franchisee of BHH Affiliates, LLC. Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices and the Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices symbol are registered service marks of Columbia Insurance Company, a Berkshire Hathaway affiliate. Equal Housing Opportunity.


Agent License Information:  

309 West Fourth Street, Quarryville, PA 17566
717-786-1300

Login to Saved Search

Pixel